By Phil Shelley
As an engineer interested in renewable energy, I’ve long considered the viability of electric propulsion for marine vessels.
In recent years, large vessels such as cruise ships, ferries and tugboats have increasingly adopted hybrid electric drives. Now that solar panels have become more efficient and dramatically cheaper, I decided to try converting a medium-sized hull to a solar-electric hybrid.
Selecting the boat
Because this was a prototype, I wanted a hull that was big enough to provide the solar panel surface area I needed, had the weight carrying capacity for lots of batteries as well as useful space for travel but was cheap enough in case I messed up the whole project. After watching various broker sites, I found a boat in Kenosha, Wisconsin, that had been stored outside, was saturated in mold, had leaking heads and holding tanks, and smelled bad enough to deter most buyers. This allowed me to negotiate a price I could afford.
After purchasing the boat in April 2016, I moved it into the Southport Marina building in Kenosha. The 1986 Carver 4207 had twin Crusader 350s with only 540 hours of running time, which meant it had spent most of its life in the slip. The hull was sound, the shafts and props were good, but the dramatic change in propulsion meant it would need new props.
A bad odor permeated the interior, a 1980s time capsule, but overall the boat was solid and a major re-fit would also fix the smell.
My first job was to remove the engines, holding tanks, heads, all pipes, miles of electrical wiring, engine harnesses, both sets of helm controls, control cables, radar, trim tabs and servos, gauges, batteries, through-hull valves, transducers, carpets, generator, batteries, fungi from the walls, refrigerator, water pipes, water tank, fuel lines, lighting, and canvas—you get the idea.
Next came cleanup and engine room paint. The Elco electric motors required new steel engine mounts to be constructed. Next, I installed digital CANbus control cables, new digital helm controls and digital displays.
Adding solar panels
Next came the solar panel structure, which I designed and had fabricated by a Kenosha welding shop. Although it won’t win any beauty contests, I wanted something functional, strong and cost-effective. I used high-efficiency 250-watt black monocrystalline solar panels: 12 of them connected in three banks of four gives me a realistic maximum power of around 2.5 kilowatts. The panels feed into a MPPT 96-volt solar charge controller from Australia. Unbelievably, I could not find a suitable controller made in the U.S.
With this amount of solar energy, I can charge the battery bank in about two to three days of bright sunshine. In continuous bright sunshine, the panels alone could power the boat at 2.5 knots.
Installing the batteries
I wanted a battery bank big enough to run for five to eight hours at cruising speed, which for this boat is about 5.5 knots. I considered lithium batteries, but the cost and complexity of the charge control system was a disincentive.
I had removed about 2,200 pounds of engines and transmission and added 800 pounds of solar panels and structure high up, so the boat’s center of mass and buoyancy concerned me. I looked for high-power lead acid batteries and found an interesting AGM design produced originally for cellphone tower backup systems. Rated at 200 amp-hours, these beautiful batteries weigh 135 pounds each, solving my weight distribution issue. I decided to use 26: 24 for propulsion and two for the house, generator starter and windlass. The 26 batteries store about 55 kilowatt-hours for propulsion and house needs. To preserve their life, I aim to use them at no more than 60 percent. The battery bank for propulsion consists of three banks of eight batteries in series, nominally running at 96 volts. I had custom battery boxes fabricated to fit into the center bilge and on top of the engine room stringers.
This hybrid propulsion system has three ways of providing power to the batteries and then to the digitally controlled induction motors and other electrical needs. I have five 2.5-kilowatt 96-volt ElCon chargers that can run at 120 or 240 volts at either 50 or 60 hertz, which is useful for international travel. I wanted to use 240 volts for the chargers, as they are more efficient at a higher voltage. The chargers can connect to shore power or to generator power using a new 16-kilowatt Northern Lights unit.
The main battery banks power the boat’s electrical systems at 96 volts via four 5-kilowatt 120-volt inverters. I use a conventional charger to charge the 12-volt house battery. The inverters directly power the 120-volt outlets, galley and heat pumps. The battery banks provide propulsion and all forms of vessel power, making this a simple concept to manage.
The battery banks can be isolated into separate port and starboard configurations in case something bad happens. Also just in case, any inverter, charger or solar input can connect to either battery bank separately or all together in a single combined bank. I designed and built both AC and DC patch panels, which are capable of distributing power between all the charging and power consumption systems.
Adding the propulsion system
For propulsion, I used marinized Elco three-phase digitally controlled AC motors (the same concept as many electric cars). Induction motors have only a single moving part with no brushes and are tough enough for use in industrial drives. The Curtis controllers invert the 96-volt DC battery supply into variable speed three-phase AC. The motors run from zero to full speed in any increment, forward or astern, so turning the props at 1 rpm is entirely possible. With the digital control taking care of things, I can go from full forward to full astern instantly, which is nice for docking. This type of electric motor provides full torque at any speed.
Elco makes some elegant, if somewhat expensive, digitally controlled marine motors. I didn’t go with the largest motors because I wanted to optimize runtime and performance. I wanted just enough power to give me somewhere around 6 knots at 6 kilowatts per side/motor. This should give me about 3 to 5 hours running time on batteries alone or indefinite running time with the generator and solar systems charging the batteries. The motors each produce up to 15 kilowatts at peak power, but I don’t intend to run them at that level except in an emergency. The new direct drive motors have no need for a transmission. I like the simplicity of this concept.
I cleaned and converted the gasoline tanks to diesel. The 400 gallons of diesel combined with solar power should give me a range of about 2,500 nautical miles, five to 10 times greater than the original gasoline design, depending on cruising speed.
Getting the boat on the water
The trials highlighted no major issues, which made me smile, considering the project’s scale and 10-week timeframe. I took the boat out several times, up to Racine, Wisconsin, and back one day with just a few minor issues to fix.
The motors ran at only about 350 rpm because the original props were far too coarse for these new motors. Expecting that, I ordered custom 10-inch pitch props. Along with fitting the props, I have a lot of work to do over the winter, including fitting out the interior, fixing leaky hatches, repairing damaged canvas, installing electronics and more.
A certified engineer, Phil Shelley of Waukegan Sail & Power Squadron/20 holds a Ph.D. in biomedical engineering. He was born in the United Kingdom and has worked in the UK, Germany and the U.S. He is an industry expert and speaker on big data, analytics and cloud computing.
4 thoughts on “Solar-electric hybrid power refit”
Hello Phil (Dr. Shelley),
I read with great interest your article on the hybrid power refit. You gave me a renewed interest in my own 36′ Trawler located in San Francisco. Years ago I got ripped off by $10,000 with having a mechanic supposedly repairing my Perkins Diesel engine which had seized while I was elsewhere trying to earn a living and paying him. Needless to say when I finally made it to the boat all hell broke loose when all I had was painted boat parts and nothing working whatsoever. So my engine (and boat) has been sitting for way too long now. So anyway after all those boring details, I am quite excited at the possibility of starting over with an electric engine, massive amount of batteries, and installing a genset to support it all. What do you think now that you have actually done it. Does it move your boat along at a fast enough clip. Say 6 or 7 knots. Is it financially feasible…?
Any words of wisdom you can pass my way (or are you looking to tackle another one..!! ) I would greatly appreciate it..!
mike (Dr. Allen)
I am delighted that you found the article interesting.
I have about 75 hours on Lake Michigan this summer and it is working really well. I have made a few modifications, but I remain delighted with it.
The vessel (as predicted) is slow. It cruises happily between 4 and 5 knots, which is the speed that I calculated to be a good cruise speed. It will cruise up to 6 knots, but at that speed, the power consumption really climbs. This is a big boat of course and a vessel with a more streamlined hull, lighter and smaller should easily do 6 knots with a reasonable amount of power. I would not hesitate to do it again. In fact, I might take an old catamaran and build another one, let’s see.
I am using less than 1 gallon per hour of diesel consumption if I run the generator, however, for a cruise of 3 hours or less, I am running it just on batteries and using solar to top-up the batteries when underway and while stationary. When I dock, I plug in the chargers to shore power and then the batteries are back up to charge in a few hours.
I did add more batteries for the house 12-volt system and change the solar panels to charge the 12-volt batteries rather than the high voltage battery bank: I then charge the high voltage propulsion batteries through an inverter powered off the house battery bank. This design uses standard equipment and is more easily maintained. I can send you the schematic drawing if you are interested.
For a 36′ vessel, single screw, I think you can certainly do a similar conversion. Expect it to cruise in the 3.5 to 5.5-knot speed range with between 3 and 6 kW of power consumption. The Elco motors are fantastic, they are a bit expensive, but I feel very confident in them, they are strong, have solid performance and are well made.
I will forward your comment to Phil for response. Sorry for the delay.
I don’t think you will do very well as the batteries age and loose their power retention.
Comments are closed.